Until now.
I've been using Buxom Lash Mascara from Bare Escentuals off and on for a few months now and I just keep coming back to it.
The brush and formula give me the exact lash look I love; long, dark, full, and separated. Pair that up with a great lash primer for an absolutely winning combination. If you like a similar lash look, I really recommend giving this particular tube a try.
Photos via Sephora